Labels: ,

Cutthroat 2026: Recap


Cutthroat 2026 Final Standings
1. Sachi (174 pts)
2. Yasmine (137)
3. Kim (135)
4. Roger (111)
5. George (109)
6. Jon (63)

Well guys, Sachi did it again! That's five wins in a row for our G.O.A.T., meaning she's won all five Challenge seasons she's solo drafted. Is that unbelievable or what?! Spies Lies & Allies (2021), Ride or Dies (2023), Battle of the Eras (2024), Vets & New Threats (2025), and now Cutthroat 2026. Sure, Yasmine has seven total titles, but that's over twenty-six seasons. We thought we would see a super head-to-head battle between Yasmine and Sachi this season, but Yasmine faded heading into the finale episodes. It wasn't even close at the end... Note: The only close call Sachi has ever had is a +28 win over Jon for Vets New Threats, but that one didn't come down to the final episode either. Basically Sachi stomped the competition yet again, as she's literally never lost!

And she's drafted all over the place too: third twice, second once (this year), last once, five once, but never first.... maybe the only way to defeat Sachi is to give her the first overall pick? Either way, congrats to Sachi for yet another well-deserved win! And below, a recap of the season via Chat GPT!


1. SACHI — 174 POINTS 🏆

Roster: Bananas (53), Adrienne (51), Michele (45), Izzy (25)

Sachi’s championship was built on the league’s deepest roster and an extraordinary ability to keep contestants in the game. While other owners watched their teams slowly disappear, Sachi carried three players all the way to the Final. Bananas provided an immediate spark with an elimination victory in the premiere, while Michele quietly accumulated points through challenge wins, crying, and sheer longevity. Even Izzy, eliminated in Week 8, contributed a respectable 25 points before departing.

But Adrienne was the championship’s defining player. She consistently accumulated points through challenge victories, elimination appearances, emotional moments, and an early Finals qualification in Week 10. By the time the finale arrived, Sachi had three finalists positioned to collect bonuses. Bananas and Michele both earned WINR +10 in the final episode, sealing a comfortable victory. Sachi didn’t need the season’s highest-scoring individual contestant—she won by having three reliable contributors who peaked when it mattered most.

Also, for fun, here are all the players Sachi has used to win her five titles:


2. YASMINE — 137 POINTS

Roster: Will (44), Cassidy (41), Justin (35), Keanu (18)

Yasmine’s season was a masterclass in surviving setbacks. Keanu was eliminated in Week 5, but Justin emerged as a surprisingly valuable contributor, accumulating points through challenge victories, elimination appearances, and emotional moments. His Week 9 elimination victory over Chris was particularly important, helping Yasmine maintain her position near the top of the standings. Cassidy also proved remarkably resilient, surviving her Week 8 elimination and ultimately reaching the Final.

Justin’s Week 12 departure threatened to derail Yasmine’s championship hopes, leaving just Cassidy and Will. But both finalists delivered when it mattered, particularly Will, who earned a WINR bonus in the finale. Although Yasmine couldn’t match Sachi’s depth, her two finalists were just enough to hold off Kim by two points, securing the runner-up finish.

3. KIM — 135 POINTS

Roster: CT (50), Lete (35), Cory (26), Nelson (25)

Kim endured one of the season’s most dramatic roller-coaster rides. Cory’s departure in Week 7 and Nelson’s boot in Week 8 left Kim with only CT and Lete for the second half of the competition. Both departed contestants had contributed substantial points, but losing half the roster before the Final made a championship run increasingly difficult.

Then came the late-season surge. Lete’s Week 12 elimination victory delivered nine points, and CT exploded for 14 points in Week 13, collecting Finals, medical, and vomiting bonuses in a single episode. CT added another 11 points in the finale with his WINR bonus. Kim nearly pulled off an extraordinary comeback, climbing into third place and finishing just two points behind Yasmine. With two finalists and a furious closing stretch, Kim was arguably the season’s most dangerous late bloomer.


4. ROGER — 111 POINTS

Roster: Cara Maria (45), Anna Leigh (29), Josh (23), Nurys (13)

Roger’s season began with genuine championship potential. Cara Maria quickly established herself as one of the competition’s most productive fantasy players, collecting points from challenge victories, crying, medical incidents, and an elimination win in Week 6. Anna Leigh also provided steady production, including an elimination victory over Nurys in Week 4. Together, they kept Roger among the league leaders through much of the season.

Unfortunately, Roger couldn’t escape the elimination spiral. Nurys departed in Week 4, Josh was booted in Week 8, and Anna Leigh fell in Week 11. That left Cara Maria carrying the entire team into the Final. She finished with an excellent 45 points, but without a WINR bonus or additional finalists, Roger couldn’t keep pace with the teams above. Roger’s fourth-place finish was ultimately a story of strong individual performances undermined by roster attrition.


5. GEORGE — 109 POINTS

Roster: Tori (59), Deb (25), Leo (21), Cedric (4)

Nobody had a more top-heavy fantasy team than George. Cedric was eliminated in the premiere, Deb followed in Week 6, and Leo was booted in Week 8. By the midpoint of the season, George’s championship hopes rested almost entirely on Tori. Fortunately, she turned out to be the highest-scoring fantasy contestant of the entire season.

Tori’s late-season performance was spectacular. She survived eliminations in consecutive Weeks 10 and 11, earning a combined 21 points across those two episodes. She qualified early for the Final, survived all the way to the finish, and collected another 13 points in the finale through her WINR bonus and crying points. Her final total of 59 was eight points higher than Adrienne’s. Unfortunately, one superstar couldn’t overcome the lack of supporting players. George finished fifth, just two points behind Roger, despite rostering the season’s fantasy MVP.


6. JON — 63 POINTS

Roster: Chris (30), Sydney (22), Brad (6), Reilly (5)

Jon’s season was a slow-motion disaster. Reilly disappeared in Week 2, Brad followed in Week 3, and Sydney was booted in Week 5 after producing 22 points. That left Chris as Jon’s final hope. To his credit, Chris was a productive fantasy player, collecting points through challenge victories, elimination appearances, crying, and even vomiting. But the roster simply couldn’t withstand losing three contestants so early.

Chris survived until Week 9, when Justin defeated him in elimination, officially ending Jon’s season five episodes before the finale. With no contestants remaining, Jon watched the rest of the league accumulate Finals and WINR bonuses while his total remained frozen at 63. Jon’s season illustrated the cruelest reality of Challenge fantasy: it doesn’t matter how talented your players are if they aren’t around to score.


🏆 The Championship Difference

Sachi won through depth, durability, and timing.

Consider the difference between Sachi and George. George drafted the season’s highest-scoring contestant in Tori, but Sachi had three players who finished among the top six. Adrienne was the steady accumulator, Bananas delivered elimination and championship points, and Michele survived long enough to become a valuable Finals contributor.

Sachi also benefited from extraordinary roster preservation. Izzy was the team’s only elimination, and she lasted eight weeks. Meanwhile, Jon lost his entire roster by Week 9, and Roger and George entered the Final with only one player apiece.

The defining statistic: Sachi entered the Final with three contestants and left with two WINR bonuses. That combination made the difference between a competitive season and a convincing championship.

Final verdict: George had the MVP. Kim had the comeback. Yasmine had the consistency. But Sachi had the team.


Top Ten Player Scores

  1. Tori, George (59 pts)
  2. Bananas, Sachi (53 pts)
  3. Adrienne, Sachi (51 pts)
  4. CT, Kim (50 pts)
  5. Cara Maria, Roger (45 pts)
  6. Michele, Sachi (45 pts)
  7. Will, Yasmine (44 pts)
  8. Cassidy, Yasmine (41 pts)
  9. Lete, Kim (35 pts)
  10. Justin, Yasmine (35 pts)



0 comments
Labels: , ,

Crown Era


Heading into the WK19 finale, the season is all but over for us as we crown Sachi the back-to-back-to-back champions. A three-peat for Spies Lies Allies, Ride or Dies, and Eras! This matches Yasmine’s three-peat from 2018-2019 with Vendettas, Final Reckoning, and War of the Worlds. However this accomplishment is a little more impressive because Sachi has now won every single season of fantasy Challenge she’s played in--including a mini-fantasy in-between with All Stars 2! What an incredible feat that may never be matched. And all this from someone who never watched the Challenge before and binged entire seasons during the pandemic.

Homework pays off!

For the finale, George still has Kyland, Jon has Bananas, Kim has Derek, Roger is cheering for Tori, while Yasmine has Jenny. (Sorry Susan and Victor, you guys are sitting this one out.) Sachi has, incredibly, Jordan, Michele, and Rachel still left. With a lead of about a hundred points over her next closet competitor in Eras, Sachi is proving to be one of the G.O.A.T.s and is actually getting stronger year by year!

  • Sachi (277)
  • Yasmine (167)
  • Jon (155)
  • Roger (146)
  • George (134)
  • Susan (123)
  • Kim (75)

In the end, Sachi finished with +110 points over her next closest competitor. With the finale over, final scores are tabulate above--we gave both Jenny and Rachel +10 for co-winning the title. Here were the top ten individual scorers: Michele (90), Jenny (74), Kyland (64), Jordan (64), Rachel (64), Tori (62), Cory (55), Bananas (50), Derek (50), Olivia (44). In the end, Sachi still had three of the top five scorers—-Michele, Jordan, Rachel—and only lost Aviv in WK15. What a run!

0 comments
Labels: ,

Ride or Dies: Rosters

  • Susan (Amber, Nelson, Nam, Sam, Ravyn)
  • Yasmine (Nany, Kaycee, Jay, Kim)
  • Kim (Turbo, Michele, Nurys, Johnny)
  • Jon (Laurel, Faysal, Chauncey, Emmy)
  • George (Tori, Jordan, Veronica, Tommy)
  • Roger (Devin, Darrell, Jakk, Tamara)
  • Sachi (Bananas, Aneesa, Horacio, Moriah)
  • Ameer (Olivia, Kenny, Kailah, Colleen, Analyse)

0 comments
Labels: ,

Final Standings: Spies, Lies, Allies

 


It was back-to-back for our favorite Uncle CT, and also a huge debut for our Rookie of the Year Sachi, as she headed into the final episode with a commanding forty point plus lead. Roger had Nelson and Devin up against Sachi's Emy and Kyle, but short of a miracle, Sachi was taking home the crown.

With such a veteran heavy season, most of our top picks did well -- Kaycee, CT, Tori, Kyle, Devin, Nany were the first six of seven picks -- but it was the rookie Emy that powered the season with her multiple elimination wins, her many cries, and her shout outs to her grandmother and Romania. Sachi's team ended up having Emy and Kyle in the top five scorers, and it could've been possibly more, with Ashely DQing midway through the season.

For third place, Kim put up a good fight but losing Emanuel hurt her in the end, and she finished just a handful of points behind Roger. A tier below was George and Yasmine, who rode Tori and Kaycee as far as they could, respectively. Despite leading the season early, Jon flamed out and dropped to the bottom of the standings, joining Susan and Victor there.

We hope next season won't be as veteran dominated and we hope Emy can be allowed to come back. For now, congrats to our first time owner, our rookie of the year and winner of Spies, Lies, Allies: Sachi!

  1. Sachi (193)
  2. Roger (145)
  3. Kim (140)
  4. George (133)
  5. Yasmine (130)
  6. Jon (120)
  7. Susan (104)
  8. Victor (96)

0 comments
Labels: ,

Spies, Lies, Allies (SLA): Rosters

 



  • Yasmine: Kaycee, Nam, Logan, Tacha
  • Kim: CT, Emmanuel, Michaela, Esther
  • Susan: Cory, Tula, Aneesa, Hughie
  • George: Tori, Amanda, Berna, Kelz
  • Sachi: Kyle, Emy, Ashley, Tommy
  • Roger: Devin, Nelson, Bettina, Lauren
  • Jon: Nany, Michele, Jeremiah, Gabo
  • Victor: Fessy, Josh, Priscilla, Corey

Leftovers: Renan, Tracy (Yasmine)
Late: Ed (Kim), Amber (Roger)

0 comments
Labels: ,

Spies, Lies, Allies (SLA): Rules



Take a look at the scoring below. Blue is scoring that changed.

DRAFT
  • Eight team owners will each select four players each, in a snake style draft.
  • There are two (or more) leftovers, to be selected by whichever owner loses their players first, in reverse draft order.

Scoring Rules
Since there's no tribunal, we are just giving the weekly challenge winners +2 points and leaving it at that.
COMPETITION Points (awarded per episode)

  • Weekly (+1): Awarded for each episode a player stays on the show.
  • Challenge (+2): Awarded for winning weekly challenge. If team game, each individual on the winning team receives the points.
  • Elimination (+4): Awarded for being tossed into an elimination challenge.
  • Survival (+4): Awarded for winning the elimination challenge.
BONUS Points (awarded once per episode max)

  • Crying (+2): A clear case of crying, has to include visible tears.
  • Kissing (+2): Awarded for romantic kisses and not for congratulatory pecks.
  • Sex (+4): Must be shown on-camera, or acknowledged by both parties, with no doubts.
  • Medical (+4): If a player needs treatment from an on-screen medical professional, or if they go to a hospital.
  • Puke (+4): Throwing up from drinking, exhaustion, food poisoning, etc. Has to be on-screen, and not just gagging from almost throwing up.
  • Fight / Tirade (+6): For fights, it must be physical, with an intent to do harm. One-sided fights can be possible if there's clearly just one antagonizer. A tirade must be crazy-level, up to and including throwing or breaking things.
  • Booted (+6): Getting kicked off the show by producers, be it for physical altercation, safety reasons, injuries, etc. Also applies if the person quits the show.

Finals Points (awarded once at end of season)

  • Finals (+5): Awarded to everyone who makes the finals.
  • Winner (+10): Awarded to the overall winner or winners.
ARBITRATION DETAILS
Majority wins on voting for questions about scoring. Broadly speaking, we like to lean toward more scoring, especially for drama. The more points the more fun!

0 comments
Labels: , ,

Final Standings: All Stars

Well, a month-and-a-half after All Stars ended, here are the scores! Some of us just caught up last week… some of us STILL aren’t caught up. Next season we better get back on track and get the scoring and watching up to speed. Are we slowing down in our old age? Heavens no! Right?

Overall, it was a very weird season with twelve “finalists” — out of twenty-two total contestants — and very low drama all around. It was certainly exciting to see so many familiar faces and refreshing to see everyone be (mostly) nice to each other. Nearly all of the bonus points came from puking from the eating portions of the show. There was only one on-screen kiss — between Laterrian and Aneesa — and just one person who got booted/quit.

Still, this was a great season, as watching people similarly aged to us struggle — and conquer — through challenges was a thrill. I found myself enjoying All Stars more than Double Agents, which was concurrently airing. What did you guys think?

And now, no more beating around the bush…. who won?!

Coming in last place, it was George, who saw Ace eliminated episode one — replaced by Beth on her roster — and then Teck two episodes later. Kim fare a little better, having KellyAnne reach the finals, but with Arissa quitting and Syrus limping out of his elimination, Kim’s team couldn’t reach further up than second-to-last.

Our recent Double Agents champion, Roger, came in fifth place, with Nehemiah and Jisela making their mark points-wise but Derrick being surprisingly quiet all season long. While Derrick did make the finals — I mean, who didn’t? — he and Jisela were the first ones out after the first water leg of TJ’s Final.

Susan actually had two contestants make the finals too, in Mark and Big Easy, but Trishelle getting eliminated back in EP2 really hurt her potential to get higher in our standings. Or should I say “Jon’s Standings?!”

That leaves three finalists for this nine-episode. Would it be Yasmine, eight-time winner and the greatest fantasy Challenge player in history? Or would it be Jon, our laggy commissioner and blogger? Perhaps it would be Victor, who has now promised to never leave mid-draft again because auto-draft is not a thing. Drumroll please…!!!


  1. Jon (86)
  2. Victor (84)
  3. Yasmine (75)
  4. Susan (69)
  5. Roger (64)
  6. Kim (55)
  7. George (41)

In the end, it was Jon who takes the All Stars title, with a very narrow two point win over Victor. Yes, it was Aneesa’s kiss, or her many many tears, that took Jon to the title. Shockingly, Jonna performed as well as Ruthie all season, and then the MVP for Jon’s season was the much maligned Aneesa, who tied with Kendal for top points scored this season.

For Victor, losing Kendal was a huge blow, even if Alton and Jemmye did their best to capture another championship for him. Yasmine’s late burst to third place, powered by Yes’ win and both he and Darrell’s top-two finish were exciting but also not quite enough to take her to another win.

Serious question: Should Aneesa start being valued as a top player? She cries, she makes out, she never gets eliminated without a whole lot of emotional upheaval. Should MTV be advertising Aneesa more?!

  1. Aneesa / Kendal (34)
  2. Eric(32)
  3. KellyAnne / Yes (30)
  4. Mark / Darrell (30)
  5. Ruthie / Jonna / Nehemiah / Jemmye (26)

Overall, this was Jon’s fourth title — Rivals III, War of the Worlds 2, Total Madness, All Stars — and three wins in the past four seasons. He now surpasses HT for second all-time in championships, and is now close on the heels of Yasmine…. okay not really. But we must dream right?! Congrats to Jon!

0 comments
Labels: ,

All-Stars: WK1-3


And here we are, All-Stars is underway and we love the show! Everyone being our age-ish and being over the hill has been awesome. We added "+2 for reference to age (in a detrimental way)" but so far we haven't even come close to scoring that yet. So we're eliminating that.

We are adding +2 for the two winners of a group challenge, as TJ seems to have added "Immunity" and "Life Saver" as roles. If it's an individual game though -- as it was in EP02 -- there will be on extra +2 for the weekly challenge winners. Got it?

  • George (31)
  • Roger (31)
  • Victor (25)
  • Yasmine (19)
  • Susan (17)
  • Jon (15)
  • Kim (15)

0 comments
Labels: ,

Challenge All-Stars: Rosters

Of course we're doing fantasy for the Challenge All-Stars! And we're gonna use the same rules, same everything really. This is the first time we've had overlapping seasons, as we're entering the finale of Double Agents and EP3 of All-Stars. A quick recap of our rosters. [ All-Stars Scoring Sheet ]

  • George: Teck, Ace, Laterrian (Beth)
  • Jon: Ruthie, Jonna, Aneesa
  • Kim: KellyAnne, Syrus, Arissa
  • Roger: Derrick, Nehemiah, Jisela
  • Susan: Mark, Trishelle, Eric
  • Victor: Alton, Kendal, Jemmye
  • Yasmine: Yes, Darrell, Katie

Leftovers: Beth

0 comments
Labels: ,

Final Standings: Double Agents

 


Well well, in Roger's fourth season -- after joining us fro War of the Worlds 1, War of the Worlds 2, and Total Madness - Roger captures his first fantasy title with a dominating performance that had the victory all sewn up before the finale even started.

  • Roger (194)
  • Susan (181)
  • Kim (176)
  • Victor (153)
  • George (127)
  • Yasmine (107)
  • Jon (81)

Led by show finalists Leroy and Cory, Roger rose up the standings mid-season and didn't really relinquish their lead the rest of the way -- the rest of his foursome included Big T and Theresa. For awhile, it looked like Victor's all-veteran auto-drafted team would contend for the Double Agents title but when Kyle left right before the final, that spelled the end for Victor as he left early and finished an eventual fourth place.

Second place Susan gave Roger a good run, but for her to climb into first place would've required either Nany and Fessy winning outright...and we all know what happened to Fessy. Still, getting +6 points for Fessy DQ-ing was pretty hilarious, just like Fessy's weak ass effort. Everyone hates Fessy!

Slightly behind Susan in the standings was Kim, who did have Amber B and Kam in the final, but that wasn't quite enough to finish in the top two for our fantasy standings. George and Yasmine both dragged near the bottom of the standings most of the season, and the less said about Jon's terrible Tori and Lolo led season the better.

In the end, we're all victors because CT and Amber B totally deserved to win and they took out everyone who underestimated them. Personally, I'm a huge fan of Amber B now and will cheering her on next season!

Congrats Roger on a fantastic Double Agents season and his first win! (Which actually ties him for total solo victories with Susan, George, and Kim.)


0 comments
Labels: ,

Scores: WK12-18

Welp, these weekly scoring updates are going terrible! We may have to move to quicker recaps! Anyhow, we've had quite a few weeks go by and a new leader in the clubhouse! Behind the power duo of Leroy and Cory, Roger is taking a possibly insurmountable lead into the final episode.

  • Roger (192 pts)
  • Susan (172)
  • Kim (160)
  • Victor (153)
  • George (114)
  • Yasmine (99)
  • Jon (81)

The good news is that Susan has an outside chance of a miracle with Fessy and Nany, but that would take a lot of bonus points, since Leroy and Nany are on the same team.

0 comments
Labels: ,

Scores: WK8-11



[ Rules | Rosters | Scoring Sheet ]

As usual this season, I'm way behind on scoring, so below is WK8-11, in segements!

WEEK 8

COMPETITION POINTS:
  • Challenge (+3): Kyle, Kam
  • Elimination (+4): Amber M, Mechie, Josh, Nany
  • Survival (+4): Josh
  • Out of Show: Mechie

BONUS POINTS:
  • Cry (+2): Josh
  • Kiss (+2): Leroy, Kam
Scoring Notes: The crybaby does it again...


WEEK 9

COMPETITION POINTS:
  • Challenge (+3): Darrell, Amber B
  • Elimination (+4): Kaycee, Leroy, Theresa, Cory
  • Survival (+4): Kaycee
  • Out of Show: Theresa

BONUS POINTS:
  • Cry (+2): Theresa
  • Medic (+4): 
  • Booted (+6): 
Scoring Notes: Toxic T is gone!


WEEK 10

COMPETITION POINTS:
  • Challenge (+3): Devin, Gabby
  • Elimination (+4): Amber M, Cory, Amber B, Darrell
  • Survival (+4): Amber B
  • Out of Show: Amber M

BONUS POINTS:
  • Cry (+2): Amber B, Lolo
  • Kiss (+2): Gabby, Fessy
Scoring Notes: Our first new hookup? So sad...


WEEK 11

COMPETITION POINTS:
  • Challenge (+3): CT, Big T
  • Elimination (+4): Devin, Gabby, CT, Big T
  • Survival (+4): none
  • Out of Show: Lolo

BONUS POINTS:
  • Cry (+2): Nany, Lolo, Josh
  • Boot (+6): Lolo
Scoring Notes: Farewell Lolo, what a quitter! But congrats on the gold medal!

0 comments